STRATEGY FOCUS
SOMEBODY WANTED BUT SO
PURPOSE
The Somebody Wanted But So (SWBS) strategy can be used with both narrative and informational texts during and after reading. It provides a framework for analyzing  stories or historical events by identifying important components pertaining to characters, individuals or groups. This strategy helps students focus on main idea, cause and effect, conflict/resolution, and various points of view.
PROCESS
  1. Pre-select a text (story, video, etc.) or real-life event for use with the SWBS strategy. The selected text or event may be new or something related to the current unit of study. Provide students with access to the provided SWBS graphic organizer template or have them sketch it in their notebooks.
  2. Introduce the purpose of the SWBS strategy and use a recent text or familiar event to model how students use SWBS strategy.
  3. Ask students to write down the name of the person in the first column and prior to asking them to complete the second column (Wanted), explain that they will identify what that person is wanting, such as their goal or motivation. Before completing the third column (But), explain that in this column they will identify the conflict, challenge, or barrier to the person’s goal or motivation. Next, explain in the “So” column, they will record what the person or group did in an attempt to resolve the conflict, challenge, or barrier. Finally, before completing the “then” column, explain to students that they will explain the outcome and how the conflict or barrier is resolved.
  4. Provide students with opportunities to work together or in small groups while learning the strategy. The goal is to provide scaffolding until students are ready to use the SWBS strategy independently.
PROBING  QUESTIONS
CONSIDERATIONS
  • How was this strategy helpful to you in understanding a person, character, group of people, or event?
  • What new or different perspectives did you discover that you hadn’t previously considered?
  • How does the thought process you used in the Somebody Wanted But So strategy transfer to real life?
  • While students may begin with a teacher-provided photocopy of a SWBS graphic organizer template, it should quickly become one that students create independently in their notebooks.
  • Preparing students to effectively use the SWBS strategy should be a gradual release process that provides modeling and scaffolding. For example, the teacher may complete the SWBS with the whole class before having students do it with a partner or independently.
  • After completing the SWBS, engage students in a Writing to Learn opportunity to summarize their new learning or respond to some of their classmates’ ideas as an Exit Slip for the lesson.
  • Consider pairing an Academic Dialogue strategy such as Think-Ink-Pair-Share or Paired Verbal Fluency where students engage in sharing and discussion of their SWBS graphic organizers.

SCAFFOLDS

General Scaffolds

  • Provide SWBS graphic organizer
  • Model how to write a response.
  • Show student samples of responses.
  • Provide examples of what student responses might look like.
  • Provide sentence starters to help students get started.
  • Provide students with opportunities to work in partners or small groups while they learn how to do the strategy.
  • Encourage and allow students to access and use vocabulary resources and tools such as anchor charts, word walls, word bank, and personal dictionaries.
  • Provide students with sufficient time to think and write.
  • Provide opportunities for students to respond in a variety of ways (e.g., pictures, text, mix of English and home language, etc.)
  • A text can be defined as anything used to gather information. This strategy can support reading comprehension of articles, videos, fictional stories, informational resources, websites, photographs, etc.
  • Use the Gradual Release model (I do/you watch, I do/you help, you do/I help, you do/I watch to provide scaffolding for students.
  • Model how to use the strategy through a Read Aloud/Think Aloud. 
  • Chunk the text to make it more accessible for students (e.g., number paragraphs, etc.).
  • Direct students to pay attention to bolded key vocabulary, figures, maps, diagrams, and photographs.

Scaffolds for Multilingual Learners

Entering/Emerging:

  • Allow students to access and use vocabulary resources in order to recount, argue, and explain.
  • Model how to write a variety of responses.
  • Provide examples of what students’ responses might look like.
  • Allow students to respond in a variety of ways (e.g., pictures, text, mix of English and home language, etc.).
  • Provide sentence stems/frames and graphic organizers.
  • Bold key vocabulary words for students to use to identify icons and match key terms and ideas to images, graphs, icons or diagrams.
  • Allow students to access and use vocabulary resources and tools, such as anchor charts, word walls, word banks, and personal dictionaries (including images).
  • Chunk the text to make it more accessible for students to sequence events, identify patterns, and locate main ideas.
  • When watching videos, turn on captions.

Developing/Expanding:

  • Model how to write a variety of responses (e.g., how to compare/contrast, describe a central idea, describe relationships between details or examples and supporting ideas, connect content-related themes or topics to main ideas).
  • Provide examples of information presented objectively with a neutral tone.
  • Provide graphic organizers.
  • Pair this strategy with Main Idea–Detail Frame to help them identify topic sentences, main ideas, and details
  • Pair this strategy with ALM’s Interactive Read Aloud–Think Aloud strategy in order to support students’ comprehension of texts for the purpose of recounting, arguing, explaining and/or discussing.

Bridging/Reaching:

  • Provide examples of students’ responses.
  • Model how to write a concluding statement that follows from and supports the information presented.
  • Model how to convey sequence and show relationships among experiences and events.
  • Pair this strategy with Main Idea–Detail Frame in order to support students’ comprehension of texts for the purpose of recounting, arguing, explaining and/or discussing.
  • Pair this strategy with Text Coding with Margin Notes, Double Entry Organizer (DEO), Anticipation Guide, and Jigsaw to assist in comprehension of texts.

CONTENT APPLICATIONS

SOCIAL STUDIES

When learning about the Women’s Suffrage movement, students determine how various persons and/or groups were involved, their motivation, and the barriers that led to the outcome.

CAREER & TECHNICAL EDUCATION

In a marketing or communications class, use SWBS to analyze an advertisement campaign.

WORLD LANGUAGES

When reading a children’s book or fairy tale in the target language, students use SWBS to write about what they understood about the characters and plot, either in English or the target language.

ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTS

Students reading a novel identify the main character, their motivation, the conflict, and the outcome/resolution.

VISUAL & PERFORMING ARTS

When reading a play, use SWBS to analyze the motivation of the main characters.

HEALTH & PHYSICAL EDUCATION

Students studying successful athletes will learn about their motivation, struggles, and outcomes that lead to their success.

SCIENCE

Students analyze different design solutions for sustainable farming and use SWBS to think more deeply about the motivation for, and impact of each solution.

PDF REPRODUCIBLE